Rutgers University Athletics

  Fred Hill: 1991, 1992, 1993, 1998

  Doug Alongi: 1993
  Darren Fenster: 2000
  Todd Frazier: 2007
  Patrick Kivlehan: 2012
  Josh Kuroda-Grauer: 2024

  Jake Daubert: 1998
  Bobby Brownlie: 2000
  Gaby Rosa: 2014

2024
First Team: SS Josh Kuroda-Grauer
Third Team: SP Justin Sinibaldi

2023
First Team: SP Christian Coppola, OF Ryan Lasko
Second Team: 3B Chris Brito
Third Team: SP Drew Conover, RP Ben Gorski, OF Evan Sleight
All-Freshman Team: OF Trevor Cohen, SP Christian Coppola

2022
First Team: SS Danny DiGeorgio, OF Ryan Lasko, RP Dale Stanavich
Second Team: C Nick Cimillo, SP Jared Kollar
Third Team: 1B Chris Brito, SP Nate Florence, 2B Josh Kuroda-Grauer
All-Freshman Team: 2B Josh Kuroda-Grauer

2021
Third Team: 3B Chris Brito
Freshman Team: OF Ryan Lasko

2019
Second Team: P Tevin Murray

2018
Freshman Team: SS Dan DiGeorgio

2017
Third Team: UTL Mike Carter, DH Chris Folinusz, C Nick Matera

2016
Second Team: C R.J. Devish
Third Team: P Howie Brey
Freshman Team: OF Jawuan Harris

2015 
Third Team: OF Tom Marcinczyk

2014
First Team: 2B Nick Favatella
Third Team: P Howie Brey, OF Mike Carter, 1B Brian O'Grady, SS Pat Sweeney, OF Vinny Zarrillo

 

2013
Second Team: C Jeff Melillo, 2B Nick Favatella
Third Team: OF Steve Zavala

2012
First Team: 3B Patrick Kivlehan, C Jeff Melillo
Third Team: OF Brian O'Grady, P Rob Smorol

2011
Second Team: OF Michael Lang

2010
First Team: OF Pat Biserta
Second Team: 2B Steve Nyisztor

2009
Third Team: OF Jaren Matthews

2008
Third Team: OF Jaren Matthews

2007
First Team: SS Todd Frazier, OF Dave Williams, DH Jon Gossard
Second Team: P Steve Healing, OF Ryan Hill
Third Team: 1B Tom Edwards

2006
First Team: SS Todd Frazier
Second Team: OF Jeff Grose, C Frank Meade
Third Team: 3B Tim Querns

2005
Second Team: OF Johnny Defendis, DH Colin Gaynor, 2B Cory Rodriguez
Third Team: SS Todd Frazier, OF Jeff Grose

2004
First Team: OF Jeff Frazier
Third Team: 2B Graig Badger, P Jack Egbert

2003
First Team: OF Jeff Frazier, DH Matt Wolski
Second Team: P Jack Egbert
Third Team: 1B Steve Normane

2002
Second Team: P Bobby Brownlie, OF Val Majewski
Third Team: P Tom Wheeler

2001
First Team: 1B Val Majewski, OF Billy McCarthy, P Bobby Brownlie
Second Team: 2B Matt Wolski

2000
First Team: SS Darren Fenster, P Bobby Brownlie, OF David DeJesus, OF Joe B. Cirone, 3B Jake Daubert, DH Mike Popowski
Rookie Team: P Jim Wilson

1999
First Team: OF Pete Zoccolillo
Second Team: SS Darren Fenster, OF David DeJesus, P Jimmy Wilson
Rookie Team: P Bobby Brownlie, OF Val Majewski

1998
First Team: 1B Pete Zoccolillo, 2B Dave Marciniak, OF Adam Neubart
Second Team: P Mike Mundy
Rookie Team: 3B Jake Daubert, OF David DeJesus

1997
First Team: 1B Pete Zoccolillo
Second Team: P Mike Mundy
Rookie Team: SS Darren Fenster, 1B Mike O'Brien, P Barry Walsh

1996
First Team: P Scott Madison

1995
Second Team: 2B Brian Giallella

1994
First Team: C Kevin James, 2B Brian Giallella
Second Team: 1B Scott Kassan

1993
First Team: C Mike Higgins, SS Bob Windows, OF Doug Alongi
Second Team: P Mike Barckley

1992
First Team: OF Angel Echevarria, DH Doug Alongi
Second Team: C Mike Higgins, 2B Joe Litterio, 3B Mike Winchock

1991
First Team: DH Doug Alongi
Second Team: OF Angel Echevarria

1990
First Team: SS Ted Ciesla, OF Angel Echevarria
Second Team: P Dave Hornaday, 2B Chris McAlindin

#1989
1B Sean Ryan, SS Mark Ozoroski, OF Eric Young

#1988
P Darrin Winston, 1B Paul Johnson, OF Glen Gardner

#1987
P Darrin Winston, 3B Scott Trochim, OF Glen Gardner

#1986
OF Glen Gardner, DH Joe Lynch

# - Only one team selected