| American Athletic |
71-48-1 |
| Army West Point |
22-18 |
| Navy |
13-11-1 |
| Temple |
24-15 |
| Tulane |
5-2 |
| USF |
7-2 |
|
|
| Atlantic Coast |
51-115-2 |
| Boston College |
7-20-1 |
| California |
0-2 |
| Duke |
2-2 |
| Georgia Tech |
0-1 |
| Louisville |
7-6 |
| Miami |
1-11 |
| North Carolina |
4-3 |
| NC State |
1-0 |
| Pittsburgh |
8-22 |
| SMU |
1-0 |
| Syracuse |
13-30-1 |
| Virginia |
2-3 |
| Virginia Tech |
5-12 |
| Wake Forest |
0-3 |
|
|
| Big 12 |
17-47-3 |
| Arizona State |
0-2 |
| Cincinnati |
9-9-1 |
| Houston |
0-1 |
| Iowa State |
1-0 |
| Kansas |
1-1 |
| Kansas State |
1-0 |
| UCF |
1-1 |
| West Virginia |
4-33-2 |
|
|
| Big Ten* |
33-110 (20-77) |
| Illinois |
3-6 (2-5) |
| Indiana |
5-5 (5-5) |
| Iowa |
0-4 (0-4) |
| Maryland |
8-12 (4-7) |
| Michigan |
1-9 (1-9) |
| Michigan State |
6-10 (3-8) |
| Minnesota |
1-3 (1-3) |
| Nebraska |
0-7 (0-6) |
| Northwestern |
4-2 (1-2) |
| Ohio State |
0-10 (0-10) |
| Oregon |
0-0 (0-0) |
| Penn State |
2-32 (0-10) |
| Purdue |
2-0 (2-0) |
| UCLA |
0-1 (0-1) |
| USC |
0-1 (0-1) |
| Washington |
1-2 (1-0) |
| Wisconsin |
0-6 (0-6) |
|
|
| Conference USA |
3-0 |
| Florida International |
2-0 |
| Liberty |
1-0 |
|
|
| Mid-American |
13-5-1 |
| Akron |
2-0 |
| Ball State |
1-0-1 |
| Buffalo |
5-2 |
| Eastern Michigan |
1-1 |
| Kent State |
2-1 |
| Ohio |
2-1 |
|
|
| Mountain West |
3-4 |
| Air Force |
1-1 |
| Fresno State |
0-2 |
| Hawaii |
1-1 |
| New Mexico |
1-0 |
|
|
| Pacific-12 |
1-1 |
| Washington State |
1-1 |
|
|
| Southeastern |
7-13-2 |
| Alabama |
0-2 |
| Arkansas |
2-0 |
| Auburn |
0-1 |
| Florida |
0-1-1 |
| Kentucky |
2-2-1 |
| Louisiana State |
1-0 |
| Tennessee |
1-3 |
| Texas |
0-2 |
| Vanderbilt |
1-2 |
|
|
| Sun Belt |
1-0 |
| Texas State |
1-0 |
|
|
| Independent |
25-18 |
| Connecticut |
22-11 |
| Massachusetts |
3-2 |
| Notre Dame |
0-5 |
|
|
| FCS Programs |
269-231-13 |
| Boston University |
11-2 |
| Brown |
6-5 |
| Bucknell |
12-4 |
| Colgate |
27-15 |
| Columbia |
23-21-5 |
| Cornell |
6-5 |
| Dartmouth |
0-1 |
| Delaware |
16-13-3 |
| Fordham |
8-5-1 |
| Harvard |
3-2 |
| Holy Cross |
8-11 |
| Howard |
6-0 |
| Lafayette |
41-30-1 |
| Lehigh |
43-30-1 |
| Maine |
1-0 |
| Morgan State |
4-0 |
| New Hampshire |
1-1 |
| Norfolk State |
4-0 |
| North Carolina Central |
1-0 |
| Pennsylvania |
6-11 |
| Princeton |
17-53-1 |
| Richmond |
6-0-1 |
| Texas Southern |
1-0 |
| Villanova |
8-7 |
| Wagner |
2-0 |
| William & Mary |
6-4 |
| Yale |
2-11 |
|
|
| Other Programs |
185-109-20 |
| Albright |
2-0 |
| Alfred |
3-0 |
| ASTP (Rutgers) |
1-0 |
| Bethany |
0-1 |
| Brooklyn College |
0-1 |
| Catholic |
1-1 |
| CCNY |
7-0 |
| Columbia Athletic Club |
1-1-1 |
| Crescent Athletic Club |
1-1 |
| Detroit |
0-1 |
| Dickinson |
1-0 |
| Drexel |
1-0 |
| Elizabeth Athletic Club |
0-2 |
| Fort Monmouth |
1-0-1 |
| Fort Wadsworth |
1-0 |
| Franklin & Marshall |
3-4-2 |
| George Washington |
2-1 |
| Great Lakes Naval Transport Station |
0-1 |
| Hamilton |
4-0 |
| Hamilton Fish All-Stars |
1-0 |
| Hampden-Sydney |
2-0 |
| Haverford |
5-9-3 |
| Hobart |
2-0 |
| Hoboken Naval Transport Station |
1-0 |
| Irvington Athletic Club |
0-1 |
| Jefferson Med School |
0-1 |
| Johns Hopkins |
3-0 |
| Knickerbocker Athletic Club |
0-1 |
| League Island Marines |
1-0 |
| Lebanon Valley |
1-0 |
| Manhattan |
3-3 |
| Manhattan Athletic Club |
3-0 |
| Marietta |
4-0 |
| Muhlenberg |
6-0-1 |
| New Jersey Athletic Club |
1-0 |
| New York Agricultural College |
1-0 |
| New York Athletic Club |
2-2 |
| New York Law |
1-0 |
| New York Univ. |
23-18-2 |
| Newark Athletic Club |
2-0 |
| Newport NR |
1-0 |
| Ohio Wesleyan |
1-0-1 |
| Orange Athletic Club |
1-3 |
| Pelham Bay Naval Transport Station |
1-0 |
| Penn Medical |
0-0-1 |
| Penn Military |
4-1-1 |
| Providence |
3-1-1 |
| Quantico Marines |
0-1 |
| Rensselaer Poly |
5-0 |
| Rhode Island State |
1-0 |
| Ridgefield Athletic Club |
2-0 |
| Roseville Athletic Club |
1-0 |
| St. Bonaventure |
1-0 |
| St. John’s (MD) |
2-0 |
| St. Lawrence |
2-0 |
| Schuylkill Athletic Club |
1-0 |
| Seton Hall |
0-1 |
| Springfield |
12-1 |
| Stevens |
28-13-5 |
| Susquehanna |
1-0 |
| Swarthmore |
5-9 |
| Tampa |
0-1 |
| Trinity |
1-1 |
| Tufts |
1-0 |
| Union |
3-7 |
| US Merchant Marine Academy |
1-0 |
| Ursinus |
9-8 |
| Vermont |
2-0 |
| Vineland Athletic Club |
1-0 |
| Washington College |
0-1 |
| Washington & Jefferson |
0-3 |
| Washington & Lee |
1-0-1 |
| Wesleyan |
1-6 |
| West Chester Teachers |
0-1 |
| Western Reserve |
1-0 |
| Williams |
0-2 |
| Wooster |
1-0 |
Through 2024 season
Programs are designated by current conference affiliation, not necessarily the conference at the time of playing Rutgers.
* - record in parentheses indicates Big Ten Conference games since 2014
