In 1992, the U.S. Fencing Coaches Association retroactively classified as first team All-Americans all first- through fourth-place finishers in the NCAA Championships, second team All-Americans fifth- through eighth-place finishers, and third-team All-Americans ninth- through 12
th-place finishers.
Men’s First Team All-Americans
| Name |
Weapon |
Years (NCAA Finish) |
| Benjamin Igoe |
Saber |
2007 (3rd) |
| Benjamin Igoe |
Saber |
2004 (3rd) |
| Paul Luciano |
Epee |
1996 (4th) |
| John Gringeri |
Epee |
1995 (4th) |
| Robert Frenson |
Epee |
1977 (2nd) |
| Paul Pesthy |
Epee |
1966 (2nd) |
| Paul Pesthy |
Epee |
1965 (1st) |
| Paul Pesthy |
Epee |
1964 (1st) |
| Eugene Legoff |
Epee |
1956 (4th) |
| Rudolph Salvato |
Foil |
1952 (4th) |
| Alex Treves |
Sabre |
1950 (1st) |
| Alex Treves |
Sabre |
1949 (1st) |
| Ralph Tedeschi |
Foil |
1949 (1st) |
| Morris Rudolph |
Sabre |
1942 (3rd) |
| Morris Rudolph |
Foil |
1941 (3rd) |
Women’s First Team All-Americans
| Name |
Weapon |
Years (NCAA Finish) |
| Alexis Jamal |
Saber |
2003 (1st) |
Men’s Second Team All-Americans
| Name |
Weapon |
Years (NCAA Finish) |
| Benjamin Igoe |
Saber |
2006 (7th) |
| Benjamin Igoe |
Saber |
2005 (8th) |
| Jason Henderson |
Foil |
2004 (8th) |
| Donovan Holtz |
Epee |
2002 (7th) |
| Yevgeni Niyzov |
Epee |
2000 (8th) |
| John Gringeri |
Epee |
1997 (8th) |
| John Gringeri |
Epee |
1996 (8th) |
| Darren Barreiro |
Epee |
1991 (6th) |
| John Toomer |
Saber |
1989 (6th) |
| John Toomer |
Saber |
1988 (6th) |
| Ian Schenck |
Foil |
1987 (7th) |
| John Toomer |
Saber |
1987 (8th) |
| John Urban |
Epee |
1984 (8th) |
| Frank Pinto |
Foil |
1980 (7th) |
| Phillip Mathis |
Foil |
1976 (5th) |
| Steve Dzincielewski |
Epee |
1978 (5th) |
| Bruce White |
Saber |
1954 (6th) |
| Walter Brackleman |
Epee |
1953 (7th) |
| John Herts |
Foil |
1961 (8th) |
| Dave Tedeschi |
Foil |
1950 (6th) |
| Morris Rudolph |
Foil |
1942 (5th) |
| Lawrence Alexander |
Foil |
1941 (5th) |
Women’s Second Team All-Americans
| Name |
Weapon |
Years (NCAA Finish) |
| Alexis Jemal |
Saber |
2001 (5th) |
| Alison Motto |
Epee |
1997 (6th) |
| Laura Cunningham |
Epee |
1997 (9th) |
| Laura Cunningham |
Epee |
1996 (9th) |
Men’s Third Team All-Americans
| Name |
Weapon |
Years (NCAA Finish) |
| Jason Henderson |
Epee |
2006 (12th) |
| Jesse Schibilia |
Foil |
2004 (10th) |
| Jesse Schibilia |
Foil |
2002 (11th) |
| John Gringeri |
Epee |
1996 (10th) |
| Earl Herbert |
Epee |
1988 (12th) |
| Gabor Sorad |
Saber |
1990 (9th) |
| Phillip Mathis |
Foil |
1974 (10th) |
| Walter Brackleman |
Epee |
1954 (9th) |
| Paul Primamore |
Foil |
1954 (10th) |
| Paul Primamore |
Foil |
1953 (9th) |
| Bruce White |
Saber |
1953 (11th) |
| Peter Kuker |
Epee |
1950 (11th) |
| Jay Funstan |
Epee |
1949 (11th) |
Women’s Third Team All-Americans
| Name |
Weapon |
Years (NCAA Finish) |
| Danielle Henderson |
Epee |
2007 (12th) |
| Alexis Jemal |
Saber |
2002 (10th) |
| Nele Foellmer |
Foil |
2000 (10th) |
| Jennifer Bosch |
Epee |
1999 (12th) |
| Laura Cunningham |
Epee |
1998 (11th) |
| Melissa Da Silva |
Foil |
1997 (10th) |
| Melissa Da Silva |
Foil |
1996 (12th) |
