The newly reformatted 2023 Challenge Cup was the first time that the tournament ran as an in-season campaign with games throughout the course of the regular season since it started in 2020. Each NWSL team played six games with the top four clubs going on to play a two-round elimination round to crown the tournament’s champion.
After their first six matches, the Courage found themselves as the No. 3 seed in elimination play. The club took down No. 2 Kansas City, 1-0, to set themselves up to take on Racing Louisville FC for the trophy. In the win over KC, Murphy recorded two saves en route to the clean sheet.
The championship, which took place on Saturday, September 9, saw the Courage claim a 2-0 victory to earn the Challenge Cup crown for the second-straight season. In the victory, Murphy recorded one save, while Tagliaferri recorded six minutes on the pitch.
Throughout the Challenge Cup, both alumni played a significant role in the success of their club. In six games played, Tagliaferri earned five starts, scoring two goals and adding one assist.