Sellers was coached by the late Tom Young, one of the greatest coaches in Rutgers history. Young coached at RU from 1973 to 1985 and had a unique relationship with Sellers. Young passed a few years ago after a battle with cancer and Sellers credited Young for his success at RU.
“Tom Young turned us boys into young men and I give Tom a lot of credit,” Sellers said when Young passed. "He took all the guys that Dick Vitale recruited and took us all to the next step. He had no idea what he was getting into, but it didn't take him very long to lead us to success. Tom trusted me to lead the team. Tom and I used to joke all the time. He used to joke and remind me that he was the coach and I was the player. We used to laugh about things like that."
During his second season at RU, Sellers led his team back to the NIT with 23.2 points per game and shooting a staggering 44.6 percent from the field. In year three in Scarlet, Sellers continued to ascend becoming a third-team All-American in 1975 and leading RU to a 22-7 record marking the school’s first NCAA Tournament appearance. Sellers averaged 22.7 points-per-game and scored 29 points in RU’s first-round 91-78 loss to Louisville.
This aggressive athlete set the tone for the 31-2 Scarlet Knights in 1975-76 with 19.2 points per game and 10.2 rebounds. He was a second-team All-American and won the Haggerty Award as the Metropolitan New York area's top performer for the second-straight season.
The 1975-76 team started 31-0, winning games over Princeton (54-53), UConn (93-79), and VMI (91-75) to advance to the Final Four.